JFET testing as 2 Diodes

Gast #6273935
Lesenswert?
• ▲
▼
Hi.

I have used two different GM328 transistor testers that have both tested 
J111 and J105 JFETs as 2 Diodes. Why is that?

A Peak Atlas DCA had tested the transistors as JFET.

Conversely, I have tested J201 JFET which one tester had tested as NPN 
BJT and the other as JFET. That could be calibration, components or 
software.

I look forward to your replies about the 2 Diodes. I believe there may 
be something could be corrected.

Thank you.

Ken
#6274260
Lesenswert?
• ▲
▼
Ken schrieb:
> I have used two different GM328 transistor testers that have both tested
> J111 and J105 JFETs as 2 Diodes. Why is that?

Could be a bug. What firmware version is running on those? I had a 
similar problem in the past when my transistor tester would identify a 
npn Transistor as 2 diodes. I updated the firmware to the last release 
from the Wiki (AVR Transistortester) and the problem vanished.

Technically this is not unplausible. The npn structure of a transistor 
is similar to a double diode. Same goes for a JFET, where the gate is 
insulated from both drain and source by a pn-junction.
#6274922
Lesenswert?
• ▲
▼
Thank you for your reply, Axel.

The firmware is version 1.11K on the new tester.

I understand the construction of the JFETs.

The issue may be the J111 and J105 have a higher VGS (over 5V) and the 
tester does not correctly identify them. It could be the JFET spec. 
Because the tester correctly tests all JFET with a VGS under 5V such as 
the J112, J201, 2N5485.

I am willing to give updating the firmware a try.
#6275378
Lesenswert?
• ▲
▼
Ken C. schrieb:
> The issue may be the J111 and J105 have a higher VGS (over 5V) and the
> tester does not correctly identify them. It could be the JFET spec.
> Because the tester correctly tests all JFET with a VGS under 5V such as
> the J112, J201, 2N5485.

Right. If the pinch-off voltage is higher than 5V, then the tester 
cannot drive the JFET to the point where Ids becomes zero. Still it 
should not identify the device as two diodes, because the Drain-Source 
connection is low-resistance (only 3Ω for the J105).

It would be a very odd double diode device where the two separate 
kathodes are connected by a low resistance like that.

Antwort schreiben

Hinweis: der ursprüngliche Beitrag ist mehr als 6 Monate alt. Bitte hier nur auf die ursprüngliche Frage antworten, für neue Fragen einen neuen Beitrag erstellen.

Formatierung
  • [c]C-Code[/c]
  • [code]Code in anderen Sprachen, ASCII-Zeichnungen[/code]
  • [math]Formel in LaTeX-Syntax[/math]
  • [[Titel]] – Link zu einem Artikel
  • Verweis auf einen anderen Beitrag: Rechtsklick auf dessen Beitrags-ID (#8078628), „Adresse kopieren“, in den Text einfügen

Mehr zur Formatierung

Längeren Sourcecode als Anhang, nicht in den Text. JPG nur für Fotos und Scans; Zeichnungen und Screenshots als PNG oder GIF. Siehe Bildformate.

Schon registriert? Anmelden

Wird nicht angezeigt. Wir schicken dir einen Link; sobald du damit bestätigst, erscheint dein Beitrag.

Mit dem Abschicken legst du einen kostenlosen Account an und erkennst die Nutzungsbedingungen und die Datenschutzerklärung an.